part II3 Sep 2012 14:56
With multiple other drilling targets in the pipeline, including the fully permitted targets at Railroad and Bouse, the potential reward for Vane investors is considerable. Downside risk on the other hand should be largely mitigated by revenues from Mexico, obviating any need for dilution – a true rarity for a junior exploration company.At the time of writing, the market capitalization of VML stands at £3.32m. Given its indicated margins on anticipated annual revenues of $11m, and its cash position of $2.8m, on a fundamental basis Vane represents remarkable value. By trading close to cash value, the market is essentially not attaching any value to the cashcow gold/silver operations, nor the considerable upside potential from any Cu porphyry discovery, nor the other assets including a NI 43-101 compliant uranium breccia pipe resource at Wate (despite recent merger and acquisition activity in the area). Fair value for Vane would include consideration of its revenues, assets, and exploration potential. As Vane is committed to creating shareholder value primarily through exploration success, the majority of free cash flow is re-invested to fund drilling campaigns. This makes common metrics for the valuation of junior gold producers (e.g. P/E ratios) less suitable, so here a price-to-sales ratio (PSR) is applied.
Currently, Vane's PSR is 0.5 (share price of 0.8p divided by revenues per share of 1.6p). This compares to a precious metals sector average of 5.27 (based on a basket of 84 gold producers). Given the relatively small scale of Vane's gold/silver mining operations (~5 koz pa Au, ~100 koz pa Ag) and its 80/20 profit sharing joint-venture, a discount to this PSR should be applied; here, a PSR of 2 is suggested, corresponding with a share price of 3.2p at current levels of production. This increases by 0.2p for each $100 increase in the price of gold over $1600 (assuming proportionally higher silver prices). Additionally, if Vane's potential to triple production is realized, this would suggest a 9.6p share price (increasing by 0.6p for each $100 increase in POG). Secondly, Vane's assets include a portfolio of ~270 uranium breccia pipe projects in Arizona on lands intended for mining, a wholly owned mill capable of processing 2700 tonnes per month, and a cyanide leach/Merrill Crowe recovery plant. Vane estimates the total value of these assets at £7.34m, with cash reserves estimated at £3.5m (Q3 2012), and debt of £1m in the form of a convertible loan note. Additionally, the NI 43-101 compliant uranium resource of 1.118m lbs (Wate) can be assigned an in-situ value based on lbs uranium outlined. Octagon Capital calculated a sector average for junior uranium explorers of $3.09/lb, suggesting an in-situ value for Wate of $3.45m (£2.2m). Taken together, the net asset value of Vane is estimated at £12m GBP, or 2.7p per share.