RE: Choices4 Feb 2021 11:31
Eye_Wink - some additional thoughts for you, as I am in the same position although a lower tax band one.
1. Speculation is the CGT tax free amount will be reduced significantly from the £12,300 currently enjoyed (rumour £2,000). CGT rates of Tax may also be aligned with income tax for the next tax year, thus 20/40/45% depending on your marginal rate vs the current 10/20% for basic/High rate payers.
If you sold now and made a CGT loss (you said your underwater on shares presently), I'm reasonably certain that loss can be carried forward into the next tax years (not sure how many years you can do so but believe it's multi year). The benefit being it should mitigate any future CGT gains from profitable sales of other shares/assets (property etc). Of course, this only applies if you become profitable on your folio of shares/assets and then you will be offsetting profits against a potential 40% future tax rate. It might be useful for example if you were to sell TSCO now and then buy back to avoid the dividend tax/share consolidation and to speculate on future gains in the shares.
2. If you take the dividend, your tax rates are either 7.5/32.5/38.1% once you exceed the £2K allowance. Again, it's highly likely these rates will be increased to align with income tax so you may be paying 40% in future on dividends rather than your 32.5% from this tax year.
3. Can you put any more contribution into your pension, eg if you moved the TSCO shares into your SIPP (or were to set one up)I think you avoid all tax until income is taken. You will of course pay tax on the income but by then you may be earning less and currently there is the 25% tax free lump sum which may also be under threat though?
So, it's a minefield and the tax situation is just speculation until the budget. Personally, as I can't move any more into ISA/SIPP this year, I'm going to take the 7.5% dividend tax rather than sell my TSCO which are currently profitable and would reduce my rather sad CGT loss position carried forwards from previous years.
Dunno if any of that helps/makes sense?