RE: Still highly undervalued7 Dec 2021 13:08
Greenfish, yes that's true, but the operating leverage here is better than AEP's and MPE's, so a small change in revenue leads to an utterly mega change in EBITDA. You also have the same effect with the financial gearing: the utterly obnoxious levels of debt and prior ranking finance (the bloody prefs) mean that a small change in EBITDA causes an utterly massive change in eps attributable to the ords. No I don't like the debt and prefs, but I can't deny that in the current CPO price environment with spot CPO hovering above $1300, the level where those obnoxious export levies and export taxes cease to make further demands on the CPO price upside from then on, we are likely to report profitability that hasn't been seen for donkey's years (See my forecast of 8p eps attributable to the ords for FY2021 on the ADVFN threads - no, I am not confident in the method I used of assuming the same levels of gearing to forecast the EBITDA figure, but we will see if I am anywhere near close next May).
Even our chairman acknowledges we are entering a period of prosperity. Yes, he is careful not to say how long it will last (he is a cautious person, right?).
Sure leverage works both ways, so volatile share price movements are to be expected, I wonder?
BTW, when comparing our historic miserable profitability levels with AEP and MPE, you have to remember that they DO NOT CHARGE FOR THEIR EQUITY CAPITAL. We being more debt financed do charge for our finance. Arguably, their profits are overstated compared with ours. Look at our 5.5 cpo tonnes per mature hectare - they get less. Agriculturally speaking, we are a good company. MPE and AEP have lower risk ratings than we do, but as ever you have to choose the risk level you can best tolerate. ATB. P.S. Don't forget we have had about $50m to $60m of dud assets on the balance sheet (coal and stone interests), and these are probably now going to make a contribution, something they haven't done for donkey's years. REA has about $500m of total assets from memory, of which only a tiny proportion is financed by ords shareholder funds. Imagine if all that debt finance is paid off from cash generated by operations before working capital movements are taken into account, and we would surely have an 8 bagger here. AIMO. DYOR.