What's TW up to?20 Jan 2016 22:53
A few years ago, at an evening soiree, I got embroiled in a discussion concerning the local flooding that we had experienced. A chap put it down to the effect of the tide on the river ... I pointed out that the coast was 5 miles away, there was 125 feet difference in height and there were three weirs in the river twixt here and there. But no, the laws of physics didn't seem to make a difference to this situation and for the sake of our hosts I changed the subject.
I rather suspect that entering into a discussion with our friend TW would be much the same ...
I've read what he says and much of it is just beligerently and willfully misinterpreted. Apart from supplying the wrong accounts in his link and appealing to superstition in that a rival tipsters recommendation proves that the share price must collapse -- he is just wrong on basic accounting/business principles.
One example and then onto much more interesting things ... he claims that the BoD's statement that Trak are delivering "strong net cash generation" is "*******s". The basis for this is that he subtracts R&D and capital equipment purchase from the net cash as though they were expenses and not investment for the future.
Clearly Trak generated the cash and the BoD wisely spent it on improving the business. Of course they could have paid a dividend (and 40+% would have gone to themselves). Presumably that would have satisfied TW's critera for cash generation -- I know which business model I prefer.
NOW FOR SOMETHING MORE INTERESTING ... What's this guy up to? He's not serving any higher purpose to the financial community so what's his game? I can't see how he, or his associates, could effectively short this share. And which big holder would loan him the shares knowing what he's going to do?
I think we're dealing with the sort of character who goes round knocking other people's sand castles down because they can't make one themself.
In short he won't make anything out of this, but he'll get to feel important for a while.
IN SUMMARY ... he doesn't really have a claim, but there are those who will listen, and this has come at a generally bad time for the market as a whole. I believe the board on this one. The accounts are right and proper and I think they will have done their homework about Route Monkey, their accounts, cash flow, order book etc and have already got an integration plan in place for the acquisition.
In short the numbers are right and TW is ultimately wrong ... it may be stormy but truth will out, it always does!
Mike