RE: Afternoon thoughts on offer14 Apr 2025 14:26
I think we all got this wrong, me included as I was consistently saying a bid of 50-70p. I am long at 42p. I just feel strongly that totally ignoring the market price implying that everyone else is wrong and that a bid of three figures or more was a near certainty reflects a very poor understanding of market dynamics,. That said, everyone on this BB should make their own decision and not blame others if they made the wrong one.
The one major concern I had throughout was not that S would not bid but that a significant equity injection was required. I mentioned this many times. There were always three options here, a very very dilutive rights issue, a massive debt for equity swap or cash injection by an acquirer. Personally given the price offered and without know the full details on the restatements etc, I would have gone for a rights issue on the basis that over time we would have got our money back. Clearly the insiders will have considered these three options and that is why they are saying an injection by Sidara would be the best one.
The lenders are unlikely to pull the plug if Sidara proceeds and perhaps even if they don't. While this suggests "free money" to be made at this price, the market is clearly attaching something like a 30% probability to the deal not going through and no probability to another bid. For me personally to average down to 35p would cost me too much and so I am going to sit on my hands and hope beyond hope for a higher bid. The likelihood of a bid is greater now than at any time since Sidara indicated a possible bid as others now know what price they have to beat. That said they are outside the tent and any offer would be conditional. For this to work it would need to be at least a 25% premium to the offer on the table and perhaps more to prevent investors taking the "bird in the hand" rather than "one in the bush"