RE: RedLee31 Aug 2018 07:11
"JoeBass, that $1.9b quote belongs to me"
"I would be very careful with that $1.69b NPV estimate JoeBass."
I have to say that I do enjoy reading your posts and agree with a lot of what you say, in particular, this comment,
"Personally I would be very careful relying too heavily on anything RY says verbally. Not sure if you are an 'old' long termer or not, but RY does have an extensive back catalogue of similar quotes, which if reproduced here would result in serious egg on face, a current favourite would be the PFS is a "living document"
My background is not in the finance sector, so I'm not sure many will pay to much attention to my speculative comments and opinions, because that's just what they are.
Given that you're from a banking background,it would be more prudent if you exercised a lot more caution before throwing figures out there, no matter how speculative you think or say they are, that you're not prepared to support a few days later when it's referenced. If you don't want any comment referenced, then either say so or don't mention it. If they're numbers you're not comfortable with or at a level you believe cannot/will not be achieved, then you should avoid them completely, especially given your background. " it's pie in the sky as far as I am concerned and I am the source of this quote." wasn't mentioned in your original post.
Just my opinion and I'm sure many will disagree with me, as is there right to do so.
Most people know to take comments from lawyers, bankers and politicians with a huge wagon of salt, but some still believe them, so you should be a bit more responsible.
My personal calc on NPV has been circa $1.5 bln and I have referenced this number before. It is just my view, in the absence of the real numbers, promised by RY, thats all we can do, speculate.
After all, this is a public bb, and people will comment to the upside and downside of AMC, that's the purpose of the forum.
You do appear to be quite agitated by the $1.9 bln quote, so for that, apologies, no agitation was intended.
As I replied, my point was more to do with highlighting a dismal sp rather than the NPV. If it makes you more comfortable, I will refrain from using that number again, is $1,89 bln ok ?,,,LOL,,Only joking.
I think there is a lot of frustration here with many LTH's, RY's continual failure to do what he says he will, is my biggest gripe, along with this continuously depressed share price.
I wish you well and good luck with your investments, particularly this one.