RE: EBT29 Apr 2024 09:59
Romaron, chiro, my point is not about an employee benefit/incentive plan, something I am of course in favour of, but that this was a pre-existing liability, so something they had to do anyway. The buybacks announcement did not specify that the first 25m of shares (a third or so of the buyback amount, so significant) were actually already baked in. They could argue the EBT liability is only a potential future liability, based on company results, but that would still not wash, as in that case as the potential liability becomes an actual liability, they should purchase company shares to replace the ones they are purchasing now, and that would defeat the objective of what they have announced. By all means, if the numbers work, buy shares now and put them in the EBT to cover their liability, but that should be separate and in addition to the announced buybacks.
Maybe this could be viewed as all part of the game, smart/clever behaviour – I view it as crafty, and I would not feel comfortable buying a used car from someone who plays with information in this way.
I will wait to fully understand but if I remain unsatisfied, I will indeed raise the matter. I’ve put it in the same file as saying 2023 was a good year based on the big gas discovery in Indonesia😊