proppa/nezlob5 Sep 2011 15:58
You can take the 47p dividend as either a capital return or as income.
If you take the Capital Option (Alternative 1) then the total received - £1,175 in your case proppa - would form part of your 2011/2012 Gapital Gains allowance (CGT) and as long you do not exceed the £10,680 limit then no additional tax would be paid.
If you take the Income Option (Alternative 2) then the total will be received as a normal dividend with an attached 10% tax credit, and you will not be liable to any additional tax unless the total of all of your income - salary, interest and dividends - pushes you into a higher tax bracket.
Please note: The Default Option is Alternative 1. So you do NOT return the 'Form Of Election' if you want a return of capital. You only use the 'Form Of Election' to elect for the Income Option which is Alternative 2, or a mixture of the two.
So the choice depends on your personal tax situation. If you will easily exceed your CGT allowance for the year then take it as income, but if the extra income will push you up into a higher tax bracket then take it as capital. If neither applies then it doesn't matter which you choose. If both apply then you have the choice of paying the extra 22.5% tax on dividend income (32.5% less the 10% tax credit) if you pay tax at 40%, or the extra 18% tax on exceeding your CGT allowance, so best to opt for the Capital Option. IMHO HMRC make the rules this complicated in the hope of confusing us into making the wrong choices and paying more tax!!!
You will need to sit down with a pen a paper to work out how each option will affect you if you are close to either tax threshold. Personally, as i have already used up my CGT allowance for the year, i will be taking the Income Option as being retired my total income (interest and divs) will be nowhere near the £42,475 level at which i would be liable for 40% tax.
Hope this helps you to make the right choice, if anyone disagrees with my assumptions or figures please feel free to contribute, i'm always happy to learn. ATB.