Roundtable Discussion; The Future of Mineral Sands. Watch the video here.

Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

UK finance sector ready to wave Brexit white flag amid 'fish for finance' talk

Fri, 24th Jan 2020 15:11

* UK financial firms prepare for worst in trade talks

* "Outcomes" equivalence plan draws concern

* Finance regulation now politicised, retaliation feared

By Sinead Cruise, Huw Jones and Andrew MacAskill

LONDON, Jan 24 (Reuters) - Britain's finance sector is
losing hope of securing even basic access to European Union
markets from Dec. 31, as talk that the EU wants UK fishing
rights in exchange draws the industry into a political struggle
between the bloc and its departing member.

Hopes were high that Prime Minister Boris Johnson would
prioritise the financial sector -- Britain's largest export
industry and biggest corporate tax generator -- in trade talks.

But bank sources say a push by the EU for fishing access to
UK waters and London's stance that it will diverge from EU rules
are prompting them to review hard-Brexit plans that could see
more jobs than anticipated move to Europe.

Until now, financial firms running EU operations from
Britain believed that technical assessments by EU banking,
insurance and markets regulators would be enough judge UK rules
'equivalent' to those governing EU-based firms, granting them
market access after December.

But banking sources say the EU's executive now sees things
differently.

Sources from three international banks fear that access will
depend on a broader trade-off such as Britain allowing fishing
in its waters -- a concession they feel the government is
reluctant to make.

"We're now hearing very explicitly -- it's not even the
rumour mill -- the European Commission has said these are
politically linked to progress in phase-two negotiations," one
banking source told Reuters.

"As one official put it to me, if 'fish for financial
services' is going badly, this will impact the Commission's
willingness to grant equivalence."

The fishing industry is valued at about 169 times less than
financial services and official data shows it employs just 8,000
people compared to more than a million in finance.

But regaining control of Britain's rich fishing waters was a
totem for Brexit campaigners.

A European Commission spokesman referred to a January EU
document saying the bloc and Britain should endeavour to
complete equivalence assessments before June 30. He declined to
comment further.

The EU is Britain's biggest financial services export
market, worth about 26 billion pounds annually.

Since the 2016 Brexit vote, the sector has reorganised to
preserve a foothold in the EU, launching or beefing up
subsidiaries and relocating staff and capital. Many banks and
money managers are preparing for a further transfer of resources
after a transition period ends in December.

Consultants EY said this week that around 7,000 financial
services jobs will move from Britain to staff new EU hubs.

Failing to obtain equivalence could add risk-management,
compliance, middle and back office roles to that figure, as well
as trading and client-facing jobs, the sources said.

Finance minister Sajid Javid said last week that Britain
would not be a rule-taker after Brexit, even though some
businesses could suffer from regulatory divergence.

He wants "outcomes-based" equivalence in financial services,
meaning UK rules need not be identical to those in the EU but
should have the same effect.

The EU updated its equivalence policy ahead of Brexit,
saying third-country regimes like those in Japan and the United
States do not need to be identical but must have the same
"outcomes" as EU rules to give access to its markets.

But it would impose tougher scrutiny of "high-impact"
countries, expected to include Britain.

The EU's withdrawal of share trading equivalence from
Switzerland during a dispute over a partnership treaty, not
because of any divergence in rules, showed how equivalence can
be politicised.

Britain's finance ministry had no immediate comment.

COST AND SCRUTINY

Bankers say jobs transferred to Europe as politicians
wrangle are likely to stay there, even if equivalence is
eventually granted.

"The sector's approach has always been to prepare in a way
for the worst," a second senior banking source said.

Speaking at the World Economic Forum in Davos this week,
Deutsche Bank CEO Christian Sewing recognised the
risk that a trade deal would not be finalised before end-2020.

He said his bank "could do everything out of Frankfurt" but
that Britain would remain an important capital market.

Financial lobby groups have warned that if Britain does not
get equivalence, the government will lose valuable tax revenue.

The bloc is the biggest customer for Britain's financial
services exports, worth about 26 billion pounds annually based
on unfettered access.

But lawmakers from Johnson's Conservative Party say the City
could cope with the fallout if negotiations turned sour.

"London is a marketplace. The marketplace doesn't come to
them (the EU) ... the health of the City doesn't depend nearly
to the extent that is believed on having some privileged
position in the EU," said Peter Lilley, who sits in parliament's
upper chamber.

A second Conservative lawmaker, Tim Loughton, said Johnson
would not consider swapping assets such as fishing rights to cut
a better deal for banks, which have struggled to rebuild their
image since the 2008 financial crisis.

He said the EU was bluffing and would not politicize
financial services because it, too, risked losing access to the
region's deepest markets.

"It would be a massive exercise in cutting off your nose to
spite your face," he said.
(Reporting by Sinead Cruise, Huw Jones and Andrew MacAskill;
Editing by Catherine Evans)

Related Shares

More News
Today 09:48

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: Deutsche Bank likes TP ICAP but says sell CMC

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Thursday morning and Wednesday:

1 May 2024 09:26

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: UBS double upgrades AJ Bell to 'buy'

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Wednesday morning and Tuesday:

1 May 2024 07:46

LONDON BRIEFING: GSK ups outlook; Next first-quarter beats forecast

(Alliance News) - Equities in London are called to open flat on Wednesday, ahead of the latest Federal Reserve interest rate decision, while a host of...

30 Apr 2024 17:15

London stocks score monthly gains; HSBC climbs on upbeat profit

HSBC led gains on FTSE 100 on upbeat profit, $3 bln buyback *

30 Apr 2024 17:11

STOXX ends lower as auto giants weigh; investors parse inflation data

HSBC jumps after results, $3 bln in fresh buybacks *

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.