We would love to hear your thoughts about our site and services, please take our survey here.

Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Rio Tinto wins end to human rights abuse lawsuit in U.S.

Fri, 28th Jun 2013 18:47

* Bougainville residents sued over activity linked to mine

* 9th Circuit rules after top U.S. court narrows law's reach

By Jonathan Stempel

June 28 (Reuters) - Benefiting from a recent U.S. SupremeCourt decision, Rio Tinto Plc has won the dismissal of anearly 13-year-old U.S. lawsuit accusing the Anglo-Australianmining company of complicity in human rights abuses on the SouthPacific island of Bougainville.

Friday's ruling by a majority of an 11-judge panel of the9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ends litigation begun in 2000.

Roughly 10,000 current and former Bougainville residents hadsought to hold Rio Tinto responsible for human rights violationsand thousands of deaths linked to polluting a copper and goldmine it once ran.

The ruling follows the Supreme Court's April 17 decision inKiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum Co, where the justiceslimited the sweep of a 1789 U.S. law that lawyers had used forroughly three decades to fight human rights abuses worldwide.

Five justices said the Alien Tort Statute was meant to coverinternational law violations occurring in the United States, andthat violations elsewhere must "touch and concern" U.S.territory "with sufficient force" to displace that presumption.

The Bougainville residents alleged that after workers in1988 began to sabotage the Rio Tinto mine, the company goadedPapua New Guinea's government to exact retribution and conspiredto impose a blockade, leading to thousands of civilian deaths.

On April 22, the Supreme Court threw out an earlier 9thCircuit ruling that let the lawsuit proceed, and asked it torevisit the matter in light of Kiobel.

Steve Berman, a lawyer for the Bougainville plaintiffs, didnot immediately respond to requests for comment.

He had asked the 9th Circuit to send the case back to theLos Angeles district court so that his clients could try toproceed with other claims, "sans invocation of the ATS."

Kiobel was also cited this week by a Virginia federal judgewho dismissed a lawsuit accusing defense contractor CACIInternational Inc of conspiring to torture detainees adecade ago at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq.

The judge in that case said that because the alleged abuseoccurred outside the United States, he lacked jurisdiction toconsider claims by four former detainees. They plan to appeal.

The case is Sarei et al v. Rio Tinto Plc et al, 9th U.S.Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 02-56256.

Related Shares

More News
27 Oct 2022 07:30

Shell announces $4bn share buyback as Q3 profits beat expectations

(Sharecast News) - Oil giant Shell announced a $4bn share buyback on Thursday as it posted better-than-expected third-quarter profits.

21 Apr 2022 11:53

Shell turning to China to offload Russian business - report

(Sharecast News) - Shell is reportedly looking to China as it looks to offload its Russian business.

15 Feb 2022 15:54

Shell preparing to sell North Sea gas fields - report

(Sharecast News) - Shell is reportedly preparing to launch the sale of its stakes in two clusters of gas fields in the southern British North Sea, par...

7 Feb 2022 10:52

Berenberg nudges up target price on Shell

(Sharecast News) - Analysts at Berenberg slightly raised their target price on oil and gas giant Shell from 2,350.0p to 2,375.0p on Monday, stating th...

31 Jan 2022 10:53

TOP NEWS SUMMARY: Shell and BHP share unifications go into effect

TOP NEWS SUMMARY: Shell and BHP share unifications go into effect

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.