Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Pin to quick picksRDSA.L Share News (RDSA)

  • There is currently no data for RDSA

Watchlists are a member only feature

Login to your account

Alerts are a premium feature

Login to your account

UPDATE 1-Non-banks notch win in long-running derivatives battle

Wed, 09th Apr 2014 15:00

(Adds attribution in second paragraph, first name and title forDunaway, background on CFTC's swaps reform mandate)

By Lauren Tara LaCapra

NEW YORK, April 9 (Reuters) - A group of small brokeragesand large commodities companies have convinced lawmakers totweak a rule they say would have made derivatives trading moreexpensive for them and sent more business to Wall Street banksthat already dominate the market.

Companies including INTL FCStone Inc, NomuraHoldings Inc, Cargill Inc and Royal DutchShell Plc lobbied a congressional committee to change arule proposed by the U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission(CFTC) on how much capital they must hold against derivativestrades as dealers, people familiar with the matter told Reuters.Cargill and Shell have derivatives trading arms.

Under proposed CFTC rules, these companies would be requiredto hold more capital against certain derivatives trades - alsoknown as "swaps" trades - than banks. That is because the CFTCrules, created as part of the 2010 Dodd-Frank financial reformlaw, allow banks to calculate capital needs using their ownproprietary models but force non-bank swaps dealers to usestandardized models.

By using their own models, big Wall Street banks can, forinstance, minimize their capital requirements by combining thepotential risk of two trading positions that offset one another,rather than holding capital against the risk of each one goingsour. Non-bank dealers complained that the CFTC's proposal didnot allow them to perform such "netting" of offsetting trades.

The brokerages and commodities companies lobbied the HouseAgriculture Committee after they failed to gain traction withthe CFTC.

The committee has drafted a bill that will provide fundingfor the CFTC and has inserted the tweak requested by thesecompanies in legislation. The bill still needs to go through therest of the legislative process before it is passed, but ifsuccessful it will allow non-bank dealers to also useproprietary capital models.

Broadly, the CFTC's mandate in proposing derivatives rulesis to reduce systemic shocks in the $690 trillionover-the-counter derivatives market, like the one posed by thenear-collapse in 2008 of swaps-trading insurance group AmericanInternational Group Inc. Proponents of the change saidit would not interfere with that mandate, but would make therules fair for all market participants.

"The provision would simply level the playing field betweenbank and non-bank swap dealers," said Mark Klein, a spokesmanfor Cargill.

In announcing the proposed legislation, the committee saidthe change "corrects an illogical and unworkable capitalrequirement" that would have pushed non-bank dealers out of thederivatives market, making it less competitive for banks. Of the84 registered swap dealers, less than a quarter are non-bankentities.

The non-bank dealers' effort to change a proposed rule isthe latest example of how, nearly four years after Dodd-Frankpassed, companies are still scrambling to blunt the impact ofnew regulations on their businesses.

In this instance, the stakes are particularly high for thesmall, non-bank brokers. At last year's hearing, FCStone ChiefFinancial Officer William Dunaway argued that the CFTC'sproposed rules would force his company to hold "hundreds oftimes more" capital than a bank for an identical book of trades.

Small changes to the way capital charges are calculatedcould lead a dealer to hold anywhere from $3.9 million to $536.7million worth of capital against the same trade, according toevidence submitted by FCStone to the Agriculture Committee.

"If left unchanged, these capital rules will eventuallycause non-bank swap dealers to exit the business," Dunaway saidat the hearing.

FCStone does not disclose how much of its trading revenue isrelated to derivatives.

The lobbying effort also offers a window into the strangebedfellows that the years-long derivatives lobbying effort hascreated. In previous instances, big companies have sided withbanks on derivatives rules, fearful that changes would maketrading more expensive for them as counterparties.

For example, the Coalition for Derivatives End Users, whichincludes Cargill and Shell among many others, lobbied alongsidebanks as Dodd-Frank was being written and in its aftermath toease some derivatives reform proposals like higher marginrequirements. The Agriculture Committee's proposed legislationon Tuesday - titled "The Customer Protection and End-User ReliefAct" - also addresses some of those concerns for customers.

Corporations just want to make sure their trading costs arecontained and are indifferent about who is on their side, saidone lawyer in Washington who has worked on derivatives reform.

"Sometimes issues involving non-bank dealers overlap withend-user issues and in those cases, they can be working with thebanks and against the banks at the same time," the lawyer said. (Editing by Paritosh Bansal and Richard Chang)

More News
4 Nov 2021 19:48

Shell Deer Park, Texas refinery plans to restart reformer next week -sources

HOUSTON, Nov 4 (Reuters) - Royal Dutch Shell Plc plans to restart next week units shut in September for a planned overhaul at its 302,800 barrel-per-day (bpd) joint-venture Deer Park, Texas, refinery, said sources familiar with plant operations.F...

Read more
4 Nov 2021 19:38

Smaller oil firms pay top dollar for Permian land as large players cash out

By Jessica Resnick-Ault and Shariq KhanNov 4 (Reuters) - Large oil companies are racing to sell land in the largest U.S. shale formation as rising crude prices present them with a golden opportunity to jettison unwanted acreage and meet shareholde...

Read more
4 Nov 2021 16:04

UK dividends calendar - next 7 days

UK dividends calendar - next 7 days

Read more
4 Nov 2021 15:02

Equinor eyes Tanzania LNG production by end of decade

By Nerijus Adomaitis and Shadia NasrallaOSLO, Nov 4 (Reuters) - Equinor could start producing liquefied natural gas (LNG) in Tanzania by the end of this decade if talks with the East African country's government succeed, a top executive at the Nor...

Read more
4 Nov 2021 13:44

UPDATE 1-Shell to end crude refining at German site in low carbon shift

(Adds detail, context)FRANKFURT, Nov 4 (Reuters) - Royal Dutch Shell said on Thursday it plans to shift its Shell Rheinland refinery at Wesseling in Germany away from crude oil and towards low or zero carbon products from 2025.Shell has set a goal...

Read more
4 Nov 2021 13:00

Shell plans to stop crude oil processing at German Wesseling refinery by 2025

FRANKFURT, Nov 4 (Reuters) - Royal Dutch Shell plans to turn its Shell Rheinland refinery site at Wesseling away from crude oil and towards low or zero carbon products from 2025, the German arm of the global oil major said on Thursday.Wesseling is...

Read more
4 Nov 2021 12:19

LONDON MARKET MIDDAY: Pound drops, stocks rise after BoE holds rates

LONDON MARKET MIDDAY: Pound drops, stocks rise after BoE holds rates

Read more
4 Nov 2021 09:57

UPDATE 3-Weak sterling boosts FTSE 100 after BoE keeps rates unchanged

(For a Reuters live blog on U.S., UK and European stock markets, click LIVE/ or type LIVE/ in a news window)* BoE keeps rates unchanged* BT Group rises on confirmed outlook* Weakness in pound boosts dollar earning companies* FTSE 100 up 0.5%, FTSE 2...

Read more
3 Nov 2021 11:26

Equinor to restart talks with Tanzania over LNG project

OSLO, Nov 3 (Reuters) - Norway's Equinor said on Thursday it will restart talks with Tanzania's government next week on the possible revival of plans to develop major natural gas reserves found in the east African country's waters.Equinor during t...

Read more
3 Nov 2021 10:14

Italian prosecutors won't appeal acquittal of two in Nigerian oil graft case

MILAN, Nov 3 (Reuters) - The acquittal of Nigerian Emeka Obi and Italian Gianluca Di Nardo in a graft case in Nigeria involving Eni and Shell has become final after prosecutors said they would not appeal on behalf of the Nigerian government.In a ...

Read more
3 Nov 2021 09:45

UPDATE 2-Oil stocks weigh on FTSE 100; Darktrace slumps to 2-month low

(For a Reuters live blog on U.S., UK and European stock markets, click LIVE/ or type LIVE/ in a news window)* Miners recover as copper prices rise* Darktrace slides as investor sells stake* FTSE 100 down 0.4%, FTSE 250 off 0.2% (Updates to close)By...

Read more
2 Nov 2021 22:17

Fire reported on Shell Norco, Louisiana crude unit -ENT via Twitter

HOUSTON, Nov 2 (Reuters) - A fire broke out on Tuesday on the crude distillation unit at Royal Dutch Shell Plc’s 230,611 barrel-per-day (bpd) Norco, Louisiana, refinery, according to a report attributed to Energy News Today in a Twitter message.R...

Read more
2 Nov 2021 21:20

U.S. House panel subpoenas Big Oil in climate deception probe

By Timothy GardnerWASHINGTON, Nov 2 (Reuters) - The head of a U.S. House panel on Tuesday subpoenaed four major oil companies and two lobbying groups for documents related to their actions on global warming as part of a year-long probe into potent...

Read more
2 Nov 2021 10:00

California farm town lurches from no water to polluted water

By Daniel TrottaTEVISTON, Calif., Nov 2 (Reuters) - The San Joaquin Valley farm town of Teviston has two wells. One went dry and the other is contaminated.The one functioning well failed just at the start of summer, depriving the hot and dusty ham...

Read more
2 Nov 2021 08:27

BP not facing investor calls to break up business, CEO says

LONDON, Nov 2 (Reuters) - BP's investors are not calling for the energy company to be split up into separate low-carbon and oil and gas divisions, Chief Executive Bernard Looney said on Tuesday."Our investors do not call for a breakup of BP, that'...

Read more

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.