RE: Miliband’s a clown25 Apr 2025 12:04
Ed Miliband is absolutely right in pointing out that the price of oil is set on the global commodities market. Lowering taxes on local oil companies won’t reduce the price of oil or electricity—that’s simply not how the market works. However, I think the interviewer makes a fair point too: just because something is traded on global markets doesn't automatically justify applying punitive taxes when prices rise.
The original purpose of the windfall tax was to target oil and gas companies that were making extraordinary profits during a crisis—specifically, the war in Ukraine, which was not just any crisis but a direct act of aggression by Russia that continues to this day. The tax was framed as a way of making these companies contribute more in a time of shared hardship.
But the problem now is that the tax regime seems increasingly punitive. Oil prices have dropped to levels even lower than before the war, yet the tax remains. If you're going to charge companies more when they make outsized profits, then shouldn’t you also be prepared to support them when they face losses?
Take gold, for example. Its price has reached $3,500 an ounce, yet there’s no talk of applying a similar windfall tax to companies associated with this. Or look at the banking sector—many banks have reported record profits, but no punitive tax has been applied to them either. And why governments doesnt do this is because its hurting trust and its a slippery slope and ultimately lowers confidence in the economical environment.
Meanwhile, North Sea oil production is no longer delivering meaningful volumes, and many of the big profit-making companies have already left. The companies that remain are often among the cleanest, most transparent, and least corrupt oil producers in the world. They still contribute significantly to jobs and tax revenue in the UK.
So why penalize them? Selling oil and gas on the global market isn’t wrong—it’s necessary. And as a government, wouldn’t it make more sense to support clean, domestic production that supplies oil to other countires rather than said countries becoming increasingly reliant on imports from petrostates and corrupt regimes, some of which openly oppose Western democratic values?
Even if we shut down all production in the North Sea tomorrow, the global demand for those barrels of oil and gas wouldn’t disappear. They’d simply be sourced from somewhere else—likely from countries with far lower environmental and ethical standards.
Sign In
Follow the stocks
