RE: Value Trap?2 Dec 2021 11:00
Velo Thanks for your interpretation of the way things are going albeit through the use of somewhat rosy figure work. The falling price of PGMs at the moment is a double edge sword as you know by last quarters price adjustment to debtors and unfortunately there's more to follow.
Whilst the price of the PGMs basket is falling it not only means that the current profit is falling it also means that past sales will receive a credit on their invoice (difference between todays price and their provisional price at the time of order/delivery).
This is the bit in the financial statement:
Commodity price risk refers to the risk of changes in fair value or cash flows of financial instruments as a result of changes in commodity prices.
It is applicable to the largest debtor of the Group. In terms of the agreement between the Group and the debtor, the commodity prices used in the calculation of the payment are based on the prices over the period following delivery, leaving the Group exposed to the commodity price fluctuations until the price is fixed. The subsequent remeasurement of the receivable every month following the month of delivery until the price is fixed, is recognised in other income, refer note 9.
unquote
The balance on the 2021 year end was $47m and a provision of 10% was mentioned as a risk but looking the basket prices from July 2020 to Sept 2021 it shows why 2021 was such a good result with increasing prices there was always a higher profit except in the 4th Quarter and THEN the dramatic change seen in the 1st quarter of 2022 - save you looking them up 1st 2021 $2834, 2nd $3323, 3rd $4576, 4th $4059, 1st 2022 $2897 - so you see a worrying downturn in the 1st quarter is carrying on into the 2nd quarter. Net revenue was still $29.8 million. However if the basket price in the 2nd quarter continues to fall say to BELOW THE CURRENT APPROX $2400 then revenues will need to be adjusted downwards again.
It wouldn't be so bad if production was up but it is also on a falling trend since April 2018 and here's the figures in thousands of oz up until Sept 2021 25.7, 20, 22.2, 29.2, 27.7, 25.4, 26.58, 12.51(covid lockdown), 24.3, 24.9, 23.6, 21.2, 20.40
This three way hit is whats keeping the SP down: credit notes, falling prices and lower production. The management are ramping up production again but can't yet do anything about the price of PGM's but the ramping up has hit a Covid uncertainty threat so thats why the volatility in SP in the last few days. I am invested here and have had a nice profit over the years including dividend and am not worried about the future I'm just pointing out why I think the SP is lower today.