RE: Lord Adam19 Oct 2018 02:19
Well we're both right and we're both wrong ...
Firstly, neither of us is responsible for the way the market values any share let alone SLA ...
The mid point ((open+close)/2)) on Wednesday was 271.55p and the mid point on Thursday was 267.35p. But hey that's the market for you.
We're also agreed (I think) that if you bought shares on the Wednesday you would get the 33.99p (via the B-Shares) and if you bought them on Thursday you wouldn't. So I'm right about that ... and the market makes you effectively right in your idea that there wouldn't be a change in values.
Tax, by the way, doesn't come into it, as we have never had a 'deducted at source' dividend tax or capital gains tax in the UK ... yes I know about tax-credits in the old days, but they were only 'notional' and not actually deducted.
So the market didn't react to the fact that shares bought on Thursday were worth 33.99p less than the day before. Never the less they were/are.
As regards the consolidation ... the company have chosen the opening market bell on the 22nd (Monday) as the trigger point for that calculation. Consolidations (and splits) never really affect the share price (apart from market sentiment) as they simply rearrange the same market capitalization amongst a different number of shares.
But the reality is ... that if you bought on Wednesday you got the 33.99p and participated in the 8:7 ... if you bought on Thursday you didn't get the 33.99p and did suffer the 8:7 consolidation.
So buying on Wed cost you 271.55 and gave you shares valued (after the consolidation) 310.34 - and you get 33.99p later (based on the previous 8 shares not the 7 of course). Buying on Thu cost you 267.35 and gave you shares valued (after the consolidation) 305.54 - *but you miss out on the 33.99p later*.
As I said, we're not responsible for the vagaries of the market ... but on Thursday, the fair/correct price was (271.55-33.99) = 237.56 which after the consolidation would be become 271.50 ... as you will see 8*271.55 = (7*271.50)+(8*33.99).
Overall, as punters, unless there is a big share drop tomorrow, (always a caveat isn't there), we should have come off reasonably well from this little affair.
Mike