RE: More nice chunky buys this morning7 Jun 2022 17:13
Hi Mickey,
There are lots of ways to gauge SP appreciation. Atm all of them are miles out!
For a junior company the usual P&L metrics and p/e ratings aren’t clear cut. I have looked at the range of broker notes….
VSA March 22, buy TP 4.2p, a reiteration of a previous note. It’s a bit woolly imo as it’s predicated on ‘achieving company milestones’ which could be 24k or 50k. It’s not specific enough for me but 4.2p at some point.
https://caracalgold.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/03-22-Morning-Miner.pdf
ALIGN Feb 22, conviction buy, TP 2.73p. This is an excellent note. It provides a hybrid valuation based on discounted cashflow and a peer comparison with SHG. It also includes, Kili, Nya and Simba on a fully diluted basis with a rising MRE of 2-2.5Moz. As we know some of the SP catalyst have been changed albeit for the better imo.
https://caracalgold.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Caracal_Gold_Initiation_Align_February_2022.pdf
VSA’s December 21 note, buy TP 4.2p. Another well thought out note but it also doesn’t include the slight operational changes offering a fully dilutive TP of 4.2p based on the issuance of new shares to fund 2m going to 3m Oz.
The other key SP indicators are..
Listing 1p, the Feb 14 placing at 1.12p, the HNW participation at 1.25p. The RNS also spells out that there will no longer be a need for the 7th Dec convertible. That imo obsoletes part of the VSA note. Ironically it should make the TP under as there is now theoretically less dilution.
The ops update 20th May is key because it still keeps the 2m Oz kili JORC in play.
The 31 May RNS explains revisions to the TZ SPA. It indicates that the dilutive element will be little changed but rather staggered. We get a completion boost to 1.3m Oz’s.
As I am not a mining expert I look at the SP catalysts and ops updates to see how we are travelling in terms of meeting objectives.
Whilst the broker notes may be premature or optimistic I think the baseline of the recent placing which would have been sold with upside is the most immediate SP target now because the company is delivering operationally.
So I would go with 1.12p ahead of the JORC and if we get 2m-2.5m Oz the Align Note comes into play imo. Which will give a SP of 2p to 2.73p depending on the JORC.
Given the market reaction thus far I think the market will want much more to hit VSA’s TP but you never know. The POG May also have a say!
Usual caveats
Trek