Overview of the legal challenge as at 19/11/2019 Nov 2020 03:47
Elevator pitch of the legal challenge can be read here: http://www.tribune242.com/news/2020/nov/18/last-ditch-threat-oil-exploration/
My opinions:
1. The legal challenge against BPC has no merit. BPC are fulfilling contractual obligations with the Gov.
2. The legal challenge against the Gov has no merit. It will prove it undertook due diligence with best practice experts prior to giving Environmental approval in Feb 2020.
3. The suggestion BPC delays drilling is ridiculous. It’s not like delaying a taxi.
4. BPC’s contractors are world renowned experts in their fields, such as Stena-Drilling, Halliburton etc. With impeccable safety records.
5. Oil tankers regularly pass through Bahamas’ waters and even deliver crude to facilities in the Bahamas.
6. Shouldn’t planes be forbidden from landing in the Bahamas? They pollute and may even crash.
7. Percy-1 is a 45-60 day exploration well off the northern coast of Cuba, not an oil platform 1 mile away from Nassau.
8. In the extremely unlikely event of an uncontainable accident, the ocean currents will affect Cuba and the Florida keys, NOT Bahamas. Source https://oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/explorations/17cuba-reefs/background/sistersanctuaries/sistersanctuaries.html
9. The Bahamas judicial system is robust with an appeal process to HM Privy council in London.
10. The Gov is broke due to a hurricane and now Covid-19. It’s citizens suffering. The national debt is $10B 100% GDP and recently had to borrow at punitive 9% interest rates. Source https://ewnews.com/dpm-defends-us600-million-bond-issue
Conclusions:
(a) The legal case has no merit. The judge will likely see the financial greater good for the majority (IF IF IF oil is found) outweighs the tiny environmental risks involved, bought to court by a minority. The only way to know, is to drill an exploration well.
(b) The legal costs and damages of the activists winning an injunction (unlikely), yet losing its case will be astronomical if Stena delayed until 4th qtr 2021. Bahamas costs are similar to England and Wales where the loser usually pays (Source https://www.gschambers.com/awards-litigation-costs-bahamas ). In E+W if you chip in to legal fees, you lay yourself open to a percentage of the costs and forced public disclosure of your name.
(c) BPC will possibly have a multi-billion dollar claim against the Gov. ‘you owe us $50B.’….’prove it’,…. ‘OK, approve our exploration well,….’ , no’, …’you owe us $50B’
(d) The international mainstream news publicity will be good for BPC when this blows over prior to spud, especially if GreenPeace gets involved.
(e) BPC will likely issue an emergency RNS stating case has no merit whatsoever and the drill ship will depart as planned.
IMHO
Starchild
https://www.lse.co.uk/profiles/starchild/