Come out, come out, wherever you are ....31 May 2025 12:46
Why has energy secretary Ed Miliband’s favourite new government agency gone coy? The National Energy System Operator (NESO), set up in October, started with a bang, delivering an “independent” verdict on the feasibility of Miliband’s plans for net zero carbon emissions and lower energy bills in 196 densely technical pages and an enormous “data workbook” spreadsheet. Miliband called NESO’s work a “rebuke” to his critics and justification of his policy.
But NESO turned out not to be so definitive or independent after all. Freedom of information enquiries revealed its staff had collaborated with Miliband’s Department for Energy Security and Net Zero (DESNZ) to “ensure the 3 orgs [NESO, DESNZ and regulator Ofgem] are aligned on lines to take”, and other helpful prior collusion. When genuinely independent analysts looked into NESO’s extensive numbers they found them in need of big caveats at best, and at worst wildly optimistic. Since then, NESO seems to have gone off the idea of showing its workings.
Many subsequent FoI enquiries have been made to NESO and DESNZ for supporting evidence, but satisfactory answer comes there none. A case in point: recently Miliband announced his intention to award our old tree-burning friends at Drax a further four years of multi-billion-pound subsidies. He claims this is solely on NESO’s say-so, which it pronounced in just three cryptic sentences: there are “greater delivery risks” with any alternative means of providing security of electricity supply over that period. NESO offered nothing on what those alternatives and risks might be.
Ministers and NESO itself have been asked to elaborate, saying only that the matter is “commercially sensitive”. Yet the price and other key terms of Drax’s new bung have already been negotiated – and published, so what could be commercially sensitive? None of the select committees scrutinising DESNZ find this satisfactory. How long can Miliband get away with hiding behind an “independent” public body that declines to tell us its reasoning – and what is he hiding? ‘Old Sparky’ Private Eye 30 May 2025