RE: Comparison16 Jun 2025 10:15
Hi add...yes I've been in and out of ADT1, starting at 60p or so when the CEO of ATYM told a good friend of mine that he had bought 'millions' of ADT1 shares...
At the time it was the start of my journey to build up significant exposure to Silver but, as with ATYM, the true value didn't really begon to emerge until their first concentrate was produced in Spring 2024...when I exited at 235p...
I bought back at 160 but again was out before the SP slumped to 177p just as production was ramping up...the next day they made the statement about 'press speculation' and the rest is history, with a recommended share of fer of 268p...
So how is this relevant to SOLG?
At face value it looks like a disappointing valuation, especially as silver production is swinging into action but...
When the 'press' RNS emerged the SP rose to 230 or so on the announcement this seemed disappointing but I was told "the bid will have a two in front" so I started to steadily sell, up to 250p...
I am clear that the SP was suppressed immediately before the speculation.
But what is fundamentally different is that if you look at the hundreds of 'major holdings' and Form 8.3 RNSs over the last couple of years, Dundee Precious Metals had been building up to this behind the scenes, with the likes of Goldman Sachs holding 'friendly' stakes...
There is no apparent evidence of anything similar in SOLG...the liquidity is poor...there have been up to 15 or 16 serious players in the Data Room...
And while I am certain the SP has been suppressed for at least 6 months in preparation for a bid, Quady's 'diverse book' argues against anything like what happened with Dundee and ADT1...
And I don't believe we will have to wait for the eve of full production for things to kick off...
The SOLG resource is way bigger than ADT1...Cascabel is Tier 1 and the second biggest prospective copper/gold project on the planet.
That makes it 'strategic' to any prospective bidder
And finally the evidence that this is unlike ADT1 is in JCC wanting to buy Newmont's stake. JCC are the most likely successful bidder but with only c15% 'locked in' so far.
Personally I think it would be far more likely that BHP could corral 'friendly stakes' so let battle commence...
But if you look at the history of e.g. Noront, the prospective successful bidder may currently have no reportable stake at all...
Barrick, Glencore, Mitsui, Mitsubishi, Zijin, even Newmont...?