Attempt at Valuation19 Sep 2024 10:25
Can I run some numbers past people for scrutiny, because I see an insane level of upside with Atome that seems too good to be true.
Some basics:
Shares in Issue: 44,923,186
SP today: £0.83
Mkt Cap £37.1m
Average earnings multiple for a FTSE 250 company is approx 10x (you can check this figure online and adjust if you disagree). FTSE250 is where we should be by then IF they deliver on their project pipeline.
Atome are the first of their kind at this scale. The FID for their first project is taking longer than expected (due Dec), but once their first facility is built (or being built), further project finance should be de-risked and much quicker.
They’re building a very stable production business, that will produce green CAN fertiliser 24/7, at a known cost and selling at a known minimum price (see offtake RNS). They’re building facilities that will do this for decades, very stable and predictable.
Broker earnings estimates are on page 15 - https://wp-atome-2021.s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/media/2024/09/250724-ATOME-Investor-Presentation-2024-v.fin4_.-0924.pdf
EBITDA $70m in 2027 (against $110m Revenue)
EBITDA $230m+ from 2030 (full production from existing pipeline).
They intend to use debt finance and project level equity finance. It’s complicated, but let’s assume there’s group equity finance/dilution for simplicity, and that debt finance is repaid over 2 years ($125m finance for Villeta I believe, but I’ve factored in equity finance/dilution to be pessimistic).
Let’s assume the $ weakens and to $1.4 to the £ as a reasonable worst case?
Assume 25% Equity Dilution
Shares in Issue 44,923,186
Equity Dilution 25%
New Shares in Issue 56,153,983
Earnings Multiplier 10
Exchange Rate 1.4
Todays SP £0.83
For Villeta only:
Earnings 2027 $ $70,000,000
Earnings 2027 £ £50,000,000
Est.Share Price £8.90
% of todays SP 1073%
For Group/all projects:
Earnings 2030 $ $230,000,000
Earnings 2030 £ £164,285,714
Est.Share Price £29.26
% of todays SP 3525%
Assume 50% Equity Dilution
Shares in Issue 44,923,186
Equity Dilution 50%
New Shares 67,384,779
Earnings Multiplier 10
Exchange Rate 1.4
Todays SP £0.83
For Villeta only:
Earnings 2027 $ $70,000,000
Earnings 2027 £ £50,000,000
Est.Share Price £7.42
% of todays SP 894%
For Group/all projects:
Earnings 2030 $ $230,000,000
Earnings 2030£ £164,285,714
Est.Share Price £24.38
% of todays SP 2937%
You can add on 2-3 years to each scenario while debt is repaid, but they should be throwing off cash after that.
Please comment.