Pros10 Apr 2016 13:37
Further to my previous post, I thought I would jot down how I see the pros and cons of Orsu:
Pros:
1. Cash - unlike many small explorers/miners, Orsu have a significant amount of cash on hand - equivalent to about 2x market capitalisation. Whilst I don't tend to put much value on cash for explorers (they spend it!) it does mean that they can remain in the game without needing to dilute existing shareholders for some time. Cash should last for well over a year.
2. The market capitalisation is approx. 20% of net assets. You rarely see explorers at net assets (and I would never invest in an explorer that is at a premium to net assets) but this is far too low.
3. Commercial asset in Karchiga - whilst not the biggest resource (about 200k tonnes of contained copper), it is a reasonable grade (just under 2%) and commercial at relatively low copper prices
4. NPV and IRR for Karchiga are reasonable at $150m and 30% respectively. The NPV is calculated at 7.5%. I prefer 10%. The copper price is at $3.25/lb which is higher than today but is a reasonable assumption in the next five years as it is about the average price for the last ten years.
5. NPV compared to market capitalisation is ridiculous. Generally speaking when looking for takeover targets companies look for a market capitalisation of less than 30% NPV. The market capitalisation here is about 1.5% of NPV
6. In addition to the core assets they have a gold asset, Akdjol-Tokhtazan, which is for sale but which has been written down so that it no longer forms part of their net assets. Given this, any sale of this property is a significant bonus
7. They have significant, unrealised tax losses. These have been variously reported on this board but according to the latest accounts, they stood at about $222m and are held as an unrecognised asset of $44m. Personally, I don't value tax losses as a saleable asset (they can be beneficial to potential buyers but usually only in association with the other assets of the company) but they do boost the potential commercial viability of the project itself.
8. The location of the resource is very closer to the world's major consumer of copper - China
9. The outlook for copper prices over the next few years is quite promising owing to predicted shortages from 2018 onwards due to increased consumption, for example in electric vehicles, and reduced supply as exploration has reduced and the copper grades have generally decreased
10. The licences for Akdjol-Tokhtazan have been extended to 2020
11. There are indications that the markets are changing their perception of the mining sector in general and small miners in particular
Cons to follow!