26 and beyond24 Sep 2025 09:33
It’s a mug’s game trying to guess stock prices in the future.
If Mike and I are somewhere near correct for a post tax ‘26 profit of $350 million, and this were the profit into perpetuity, then a PE of 8- 10 ish might be appropriate. I can’t imagine it being much higher.
This might imply a share price of around £1.35 if my maths are correct.
But that is only likely to be achieved once the $350 million type post tax profit looks in the bag.
Of course, if some of the company’s other strategic plans come to fruition, and the volume of gold produced continues to rise, then this will underpin a higher rating. But it’s hard to imagine the market will attribute that valuation until the pudding has been proven.
A year or so ago, I thought it was obvious that the shares were going to substantially increase in value, and that it has proven. Do I feel as if a similar doubling is likely over the next 12 months?
No, I don’t.
But it’s worth stressing that gold mining is a strange business. PAF have no influence whatsoever on the price they receive for their product. This is unlike almost any other sort of company. All we can do is dig, refine and then sell at a price over which we have no influence . My point being that the gold price, which we have no idea where it will go, will be a very significant influencer of value of this business. And that’s the gamble we’re all taking, Especially as the stock price has risen so much over the last 12 months or so.
The immediate easy money has been taken
That said, for reasons that I’ve articulated previously, I remain a holder of shares in this company which I like a lot, because:
Excellent management
Their strategy
Their execution
Their diversification
The potential for a takeover
The operational leverage we get in terms of profitability from rises in gold price – (although that is very much a two edged sword ).