RE: Holdings RNS6 Mar 2019 14:56
Well I must admit that your access to public information on Capital’s sale transfer to Tosca is much better than my own as I can’t find that in the public domain yet so will wait for the holdings announcement which mere mortals have to rely upon. What I find puzzling however is that Capital have been reducing their stake very slowly here over the past couple of years so why, as you have said already, decide when it just starts to become interesting to offload the biggest chunk to Tosca at a poor price relative to potential from here when, as you say, they could probably have tipped them into the tender pot for a much better price, and then perhaps sell more in coming months in the market possibly at a better price (no guarantee of course). There is more to this that meets the eye in my opinion as it makes no sense to me whatsoever and fund managers do not, blindly make what on the face of it is a poor decision like this, unless there is clear justification for it as they have to defend it to their own investors. Perhaps they do not/cannot have investments in private companies and think that is where we are headed but of course that is speculation on my part. You have highlighted some of the negatives from running a delisted company but I do not expect that Hughes, if this is an option that has been considered, will be overly concerned about the remaining 25% as he has appointed OF to deal with shareholders and pays him as CEO to do that. Also with a fund in excess of $4bn to manage, Tosca’s stake in here is not particularly big in relative terms and he has bigger fish to fry and indeed a mark to market loss can be absorbed I am sure. The freedom to make decisions without looking over one’s shoulder and to pass almost all important resolutions without having to revert to shareholders is one which others controlling public companies often dream of and there are lots of examples and some on here will have experienced. My own experience of delisting has been relatively negative particularly as a private shareholder, as information flows often drop sharply and one is left to wait for the end game without being privy to what is going on in the interim and of course with little ability to sell the shares. So, I need to cogitate a little more in terms of my investment here but It is a good problem to be wrestling with.