RE: Zak Mir - Technical Analysis8 Mar 2026 11:03
Not a Zak Mir fan but need to differentiate his charting ability which is sound enough from his morals and principals which appear somewhat dubious.
Worth bearing in mind:
"Key Roles of Charting in Prediction
Identifying Trends and Momentum: Charts help traders visualize whether a stock is in an uptrend, downtrend, or moving sideways. This allows for momentum trading—buying during upward trends and avoiding or selling during downtrends.
Establishing Support and Resistance Levels: Charts reveal key price levels where a stock historically stops falling (support) or stops rising (resistance). These psychological levels help predict potential reversal points.
Spotting Patterns: Chartists look for specific patterns (e.g., head and shoulders, double tops, triangles, flags) that often precede predictable movements, aiding in forecasting breakouts or breakdowns.
Timing Entries and Exits: While fundamental analysis helps determine what to buy, charting is heavily used to determine when to buy or sell.
Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: Because many market participants use the same indicators (e.g., RSI, 200-day moving average), the signals generated can become self-fulfilling, as widespread buying or selling at these levels drives the price in the predicted direction.
Investopedia
Investopedia
+6
2. Effectiveness and Limitations
Short-Term vs. Long-Term: Technical analysis is considered highly effective for short-term, intraday, or swing trading, but far less effective for long-term investing.
Not Foolproof: Charts are retrospective, meaning they show what has happened, and past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
Subjectivity: Interpreting chart patterns can be subjective; two traders may see different patterns, leading to conflicting predictions.
False Signals: Charts can produce "whipsaws"—signals that suggest a move, only for the price to reverse quickly, causing losses.
Ignore Fundamentals: Charting ignores company fundamentals, such as earnings, revenue, and management quality, which are critical for long-term valuation.
This is the bit that Zak Mir ignores when pushing out his predictions:
3. Modern Usage and Integration
In 2026, technical analysis is rarely used in isolation by professionals. It is commonly blended with fundamental analysis (for selection) and macroeconomic data (for context) to create a more robust trading strategy.