Gordon Stein, CFO of CleanTech Lithium, explains why CTL acquired the 23 Laguna Verde licenses. Watch the video here.

Less Ads, More Data, More Tools Register for FREE

Pin to quick picksMarks & Spencer Share News (MKS)

Share Price Information for Marks & Spencer (MKS)

London Stock Exchange
Share Price is delayed by 15 minutes
Get Live Data
Share Price: 256.20
Bid: 256.00
Ask: 256.40
Change: -1.60 (-0.62%)
Spread: 0.40 (0.156%)
Open: 256.00
High: 256.50
Low: 254.00
Prev. Close: 257.80
MKS Live PriceLast checked at -

Watchlists are a member only feature

Login to your account

Alerts are a premium feature

Login to your account

RPT-INSIGHT-Rivals poach Publicis, Omnicom clients, staff as merger faces snags

Thu, 01st May 2014 00:26

(Repeating to additional subscribers)

* Merger delayed by tax, regulatory approvals

* Publicis, Omnicom lost a string of contracts in April

* Big Samsung contract also under review

* Rivals seek to poach firms' top talent

By Kate Holton, Jennifer Saba and Leila Abboud

LONDON/NEW YORK/PARIS, May 1 (Reuters) - Publicis and Omnicom have lost more than $1.5 billion of clientwork in recent weeks and face a fight to retain billions more,including a huge Samsung contract, just as the two advertisingfirms struggle to keep their merger on track.

When the world's second and third-largest ad groupsannounced a merger last July, it sparked talk from rivals, ledby Martin Sorrell, the boss of current leader London-based WPP, that the U.S. and French firms could lose clients andtalented staff as a result.

Now, with the deal's closing delayed at least six monthsbecause of regulatory issues, and relations so tense between thetwo that they haven't been able to solve a seven-month disputeover who becomes new finance chief, Sorrell has been boastingabout being successful in winning business from them andpoaching their staff.

Several large contracts, including Vodafone's $1billion global media and buying account, moved hands fromOmnicom to WPP in April.

On Wednesday, Microsoft announced it was moving itsmultibillion-dollar ad and media business from Publicis and WPPto Japan's Dentsu Aegis and U.S. Interpublic.Others to move away from Publicis or Omnicom in recent weeksinclude food maker Danone, pharma group GSK, electronics firmSony, and retailer Marks & Spencer.

In the ad business, accounts do change hands quite regularly- in the case of some companies every few years - and there areoften reviews and pitches for the business when contracts cometo the end of their terms. Also, none of the clients who havejumped ship have publicly blamed the merger.

Omnicom CFO Randall Weisenburger noted on an earnings calllast week that swings in the business, such as the Vodafoneloss, are quite normal. "Each quarter you get one or two bigwins or one or two big losses," he said.

And the wins are not all in WPP's favour. Publicis prevailedagainst WPP on a contract with food company ConAgra in Februaryand its BBH agency expanded its role with British Airways at theexpense of WPP's Ogilvy in March.

Nevertheless Publicis and Omnicom face the unenviable taskof defending contracts, including the multibillion dollaraccount of tech giant Samsung and the U.S. accountof the leading brewer Anheuser-Busch InBev, maker ofBudweiser beer, amid questions about whether the merger planwill fall apart.

Among any client's biggest concerns will be whether they getthe attention and quality of service they want from staff andmanagement who will be wondering if the merger will happen andwhat lies ahead for them whether it goes ahead or not. Criticalis whether there will be changes in the ad agency teams theywork with, consultants, analysts, and rival ad executives said.

"There is more than $4 billion in review for the combinedcompany counting major accounts like Samsung that could changehands," Pivotal Research analyst Brian Wieser said.

"Publicis and Omnicom lost contracts worth $1.5 billion fromfour accounts in one week in April," he said. "It's somewhat badluck on timing, but does raise some questions as to if it's morethan bad luck."

CHAMPAGNE TOASTS

As they feted the deal signing with champagne in Paris lastsummer, Omnicom CEO 's John Wren and Publicis' CEO Maurice Levysaid their "merger of equals" would enable them to bettercompete with the likes of Google and Facebook who dominate the digital ad space, which accounts for nearly aquarter of global marketing spend.

Greater scale was supposed to give the new group betterbargaining power in buying space for ads on TV, the web, andprint at a time when many global brands are looking to cut costson advertising.

But uncertainty over the deal grew last week after the twoCEOs gave different reasons for the closing's delay.

The deal still requires various regulatory approvals,including antitrust approval in China, and agreement fromEuropean authorities to a structure that would see the mergedcompany have its domicile in the Netherlands and tax residencyin the UK.

The two sides are also locked in a dispute over who shouldbe chief financial officer. Whoever takes the CFO role willdetermine how the new company will operate, hewing either to Publicis' centralized structure or Omnicom's less controllingapproach to subsidiaries.

Still, some experts said that the merger of the two holdingcompanies wasn't a big issue for many clients.

Judy Neer, president and CEO of Pile and Company, aconsulting firm that helps companies with their marketingrelationships, said many of her clients weren't concerned aboutthe merger provided it didn't impact the specific ad agencysubsidiaries they deal with.

One insider at Omnicom acknowledged that the deal had notbeen useful as a tool to recruit clients, but nor were clientsciting it as a reason for reviewing contracts either.

A person familiar with the thinking of one big consumerbrand which recently moved its global account from Publicis toWPP said it had not been put off by the merger, but that WPP hadoffered more attractive and efficient terms.

Another person at a multinational which recently moved itsmedia buying account from Omnicom to WPP, said Omnicom had inrecent months failed to maintain the relationship, that WPP wasbetter in certain areas including digital, and that the companycouldn't see the benefits to the Omnicom-Publicis merger.

"No one explained what synergies were in it for us," theperson said.

POACHING TALENT

One of the biggest accounts to come up for grabs in recentyears is the creative, digital and media business of SamsungElectronics. Starcom MediaVest Group and Leo Burnett, units ofPublicis, currently have much of the work with other agenciesdoing parts.

According to Ad Age, Samsung spent $4.35 billion on advertising in 2012. Exane BNP analyst Charles Bedouelle said the account could be worth around 2 percent of Publicis revenuesand said the review indicates how big companies areconsolidating their work across countries and sectors as theylook to save on costs. "WPP excels at this game," he said citingthe firm's size and structure.

Other battlegrounds expected include Spain's Telefonica, which is reviewing some $300 million in advertisingcontracts, most of which are now with Publicis.

WPP had the highest rate of comparable revenue growth of thebig four agencies in the first quarter, with the fourth-largestIPG in second place, Omnicom third and Publicis fourth.

Retaining talent is also a worry for Publicis and Omnicom.

WPP's Sorrell has said that for every one member of staff hehas lost to the merging group, his firm has attracted four inreturn. Both IPG boss Michael Roth and Yannick Bollore, head ofthe fifth-biggest ad group Havas, said they had seenopportunities to lure staff away from the two. Havas recentlywon an account from Gulf airline Emirates from Publicis.

"Six months ago or four months ago, I was receiving resumesfrom young executives," Bollore told an analyst conference callon March 20. "Now for the last two or three weeks, I don't knowif something happened inside Publicis-Omnicom, but I'm startingto receive some resumes from very high senior managers."

Still Omnicom's Wren said on the firm's earnings call lastweek that its talent base is "very stable" and pointed to arecent big hire: Peter Sherman, Omnicom's new executive vicepresident, who left WPP'S JWT Worldwide. (Editing by Martin Howell)

More News
23 Apr 2024 12:00

LONDON MARKET MIDDAY: FTSE 100 pushes to new high; AB Foods surges

(Alliance News) - The FTSE 100 hit another intraday high on Tuesday, driven by data providing some "fresh optimism" about the UK economy.

Read more
23 Apr 2024 08:54

LONDON MARKET OPEN: AB Foods profit soars boosting interim dividend

(Alliance News) - Stock prices in London continued to build on Monday's gains early on Tuesday, thanks to sentiment boosted by the prospect of interest rate cuts.

Read more
23 Apr 2024 08:36

TOP NEWS: Grocery inflation eases again in April despite early Easter

(Alliance News) - Grocery price inflation eased further in April, aided by a significant increase in promotional spending, new data showed on Tuesday.

Read more
22 Apr 2024 17:21

London shares climb over 1%, M&A action lifts midcap stocks

FTSE 100 up 1.6%, FTSE 250 adds 1.1%

*

Read more
22 Apr 2024 16:58

LONDON MARKET CLOSE: New record close for FTSE 100 as war fears ease

(Alliance News) - London's FTSE 100 surged on Monday, with blue-chip equities supported by an easing of geopolitical worry, and hope that the Bank of England is getting a handle on UK inflation.

Read more
22 Apr 2024 14:54

London close: Stocks jump on weaker sterling, easing geopolitics

(Sharecast News) - London's financial markets closed in the green on Monday, with the top-flight index remaining near record highs by the close.

Read more
22 Apr 2024 11:33

Jefferies upgrades M&S, Next and Sainsbury's to 'buy'

(Sharecast News) - Jefferies upgraded its stance on a host of UK retail stocks on Monday.

Read more
22 Apr 2024 09:04

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: Jefferies raises B&M to 'hold'

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Monday morning:

Read more
22 Apr 2024 08:49

LONDON MARKET OPEN: Hipgnosis jumps on Blackstone rival offer

(Alliance News) - Stock prices in London opened higher on Monday, as investors shook off nerves ahead of a key US inflation reading later this week.

Read more
19 Apr 2024 16:56

London close: Stocks mixed as investors watch Middle East newsflow

(Sharecast News) - London's stock markets closed in a mixed state on Friday as traders kept a close watch on escalating tensions in the Middle East.

Read more
17 Apr 2024 08:53

LONDON MARKET OPEN: Stocks mixed as UK data douses BoE cut hope

(Alliance News) - Stock prices in London opened mixed on Wednesday, with the FTSE 100 underperforming European peers, with a hotter than expected UK inflation reading lifting the pound.

Read more
16 Apr 2024 08:38

UK discounter B&M expects full-year profit at top end of guidance

2023/24 revenue up 10.1% to 5.5 bln stg

*

Read more
11 Apr 2024 15:56

London close: Stocks finish lower as ECB stands pat

(Sharecast News) - London's stock markets finished in negative territory on Thursday, as investors reacted to the European Central Bank's latest policy announcement and a producer price index release in the United States.

Read more
11 Apr 2024 08:59

LONDON BROKER RATINGS: JPMorgan raises M&S; HSBC likes Kingfisher

(Alliance News) - The following London-listed shares received analyst recommendations Thursday morning:

Read more
11 Apr 2024 07:54

JPMorgan upgrades Marks & Spencer to 'overweight'

(Sharecast News) - JPMorgan Cazenove upgraded Marks & Spencer on Thursday to 'overweight' from 'neutral' and lifted the price target to 330p from 260p as it took a look at European general retail.

Read more

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

Quickpicks are a member only feature

Login to your account

Don't have an account? Click here to register.