Riddler's Blog

Who do you trust?

Mon, 1st Mar 2010 - Author: Riddler

Welcome to a new month fellow traders. We enter March with yet more conflicting data coming out of the U.S. and G.B. We had data during January suggesting that unemployment figures rose, yet both sides of the Atlantic have just released very encouraging GDP figures, which leaves us with the feeling that we just don’t know which figures to trust.

If you are a cautionary investor you will look towards those payroll figures, the fact that companies are still going into administration and believe that any recovery in 2010 is more than priced into the FTSE which trades at c.5400 as I write. Optimists will look at recently released GDP figures as signs that we could enjoy further gains in 2010.

I have noticed quite a lot of posts on a number of forums concerning the value and utility of not only Broker tips, but also Analyst tips from well established magazines such as Investor’s Chronicle. On forums such as LSE and others, posters often complete hours of research and post them as ‘Buy’ recommendations, which we all use as a starting point for potential buys. There have been some heated debates on the issue of the apparent ‘ramping’ of shares, whereby only the positive aspects are mentioned, and sometimes exaggerated.

Broker tips and upgrades should also be taken with a pinch of salt as they are commissioned by individuals with a vested interest in that particular company, although the research notes attached are excellent starting points towards researching companies, due to the detail contained.

Cynics argue that if they were to have followed many of the ‘Buy’ tips contained in Investor’s Chronicle over the last 6 months, then their portfolio would be in the ‘red’ rather than ‘blue’. I have subscribed to that magazine for 2 years and believe it to be a valuable addition to any investor’s bookcase, with the following caveats:

1. The ‘Buy’ and ‘Sell’ recommendations don’t come with any technical or contextual data, and I often wonder “How can this stock be a ‘Buy’ when it has already risen 100% in 3 months and is trading on a p/e of 20+ and sits on a RSI of 75/100?” Therefore, I always look at the wider picture and assess the merits of the ‘Buy’ recommendation.

2. They do not give a timeframe for these ‘Buy’ recommendations, and I believe they should state whether buyers would expect a return in the short, medium or long term.

3. They are, as we are, slow to accept or return to ‘Buy’ recommendations which go horribly wrong, and offer views as to why these trades didn’t go to plan.

As an experiment, I am going to focus on a ‘Buy’ recommendation which I believe is a little ‘toppy’ from a technical point of view. In this week’s edition, they have Shire Pharmaceuticals (TIDM code: SHP) as a ‘Buy’ and give many bullish points as to why they believe this. What irks me is that they say “the tip is up on our buy tip (19th Dec. 2008 @ 1063p) and should have further to run”. Not only is the current share price only 1406p, which is only 40% up over a 15 month timeframe, but the p/e is now 23 which means that Shire has to work hard to maintain this strength.

Technically, the overbought signs are there on the share graph, but also they didn’t mention that the share price DROPPED to 764p after their original ‘Buy’ tip. Now that is not unusual given the 2008-2009 market falls, but I feel it is a bit rich to rely on a ‘Buy’ tip which is 15 months old! I believe that SHP will struggle to make 15%+ over the next 6-8 weeks, so let’s see who we trust!!

Digg

Bookmark

Have something to say or ask about this blog entry?
Then use our comment box to tell us and everyone else about your thoughts.

Previous Comments

Added: 6 Mar '10
"LOL, after giving a "sell" view on PSN, despite a recovery from 200p to 525p during 2009, and a only a modest retrace to 400p in 2010, Investor Chroncile have now given a "buy" tip in march 2010, which ws given back in 2009 as PSN was clearly the leader in this sector and had reduced net debt in late 2009 WITHOUT a R.I. unbelievable !!, they really earn thier money "
- riddler

Added: 2 Mar '10
"TIE and Moosh, cheers fo your views/time"
- riddler

Added: 2 Mar '10
"great blog riddler, i totally agree, these brokers are just an overview of the crowd really, just moving with market sentiment and also have a certain bias towards the particular stock due to ulterior motives, they get it wrong most of the time, for example when barclays was trading at c.55p several brokers downgraded it to 40p, etc, and when it was at the high 300s it was getting upgraded left, right and centre by brokers up to 400-420p. i have benefited many times by doing the complete OPPOSITE to broker upgrades/downgrades and it has worked very well, ofcourse assisting my decision with TA. do the opposite to the crowd as i say, they are wrong 90% of the time. ATB."
- takeiteasy

Added: 2 Mar '10
"if they were going to give out a 'BUY' recommendation, fairly safe bet would've been at ~1000p for SHP. you'd think that if these analysts knew a thing or two about techs that they'd get it more right more often than not. dunno. a picture says a thousand words, especially as it's fairly unbiased and has no ulterior motive. my broker gave OPG a BUY rec at ~90p+ after a sell signal had presented. combine that with -ve RNS and we haves today's sp of ~56p. you'd think all these people are meant to be like clever or something?! they're clearly not."
- moosh

The contents of all 'Comments' should not be construed as advice and represent the opinions of the authors, not those of London South East Limited, or its affiliates.

You need to be a member to comment on a blog entry
Login here, or click here to register for our free Member Services.

Blog Calendar

Most Recent Blog Entries

Datafeed and UK data supplied by NETbuilder and Interactive Data. While London South East do their best to maintain the high quality of the information displayed on this site, we cannot be held
responsible for any loss due to incorrect information found here. All information is provided free of charge, 'as-is', and you use it at your own risk!
The contents of all 'Chat' messages should not be construed as advice and represent the opinions of the authors, not those of London South East Limited, or its affiliates.
London South East does not authorise or approve this content, and reserves the right to remove items at its discretion.